Product Review: Esteé Lauder Advanced Night Repair versus Advanced Night Repair Concentrate
Esteé Lauder Advanced Night Repair has been a best-seller of the company for over twenty years. The company website claims that the product “soothes daily irritation and builds a rich reserve of anti-oxidants and lipids to help replenish skin’s natural protectants.” In 2006, the company premiered Advanced Night Repair Concentrate, with 5 times the concentration of the patented recovery complex found in the original. The company suggests using Advanced Night Repair every night, and then substituting with Advanced Night Repair Concentrate for a period of 3 weeks every 3-4 months, or after excess sun/environmental exposures or cosmetic procedures.
Based on ingredients, is Advanced Night Repair Concentrate better than the original?
The original Advanced Night Repair is extremely hydrating, soothing, and contains fair amounts of antioxidants and even a fair amount of sunscreen as a non-quantified bonus (in the form of octyl methoxycinnamate). The original Advanced Night Repair contains very high concentrations of ingredients that make it extremely hydrating: glycoprotein/polysaccharides (found naturally in the stabilizing intracellular matrix of the skin), dimethicone, pantethine (also called panthothenic acid or vitamin B5), sodium hyaluronate (an excellent natural moisturizing factor), lecithin, and squalane. The soothing ingredients include chamomile, which is disguised on the ingredients list in its proper name, matricaria (anthemis nobilis); bisabolol (derived from chamomile), and allantoin (an anti-irritant derived from uric acid). Antioxidants include vitamin E (tocopheryl acetate) and retinyl palmitate (a derivative of vitamin A which must be converted to retinaldehyde and then all-trans retinoic acid within the skin in order to be effective. However, when present in sufficiently high concentrations, retinyl palmitate displays anti-aging and antioxidant benefits similar to that of retinol.)
The new formula, Advanced Night Repair Concentrate, contains higher concentrations of the original ingredients, plus linoleic acid, cholesterol, bifidus, bifiderm, and RNA fragments. Unfortunately, linoleic acid, an emollient, is the only of these ingredients to have long-term anti-aging benefits, as it functions as an antioxidant and has been shown by Elias et. al (amongst others) to demonstrate healing and barrier function restoration activity. Cholesterol is another emollient. Bifidus and bifiderm have been shown to suppress the growth of certain pathogenic bacteria, and stimulates the growth of Lactobacillus bifidus bacteria, a type of bacteria that undergo lactic acid fermentation. According to Sone Toshiro, lactic acid fermentation of raw plant materials may have some beneficial skin care benefits (for instance, another Esteé Lauder-owned product, Creme de la Mer, undergoes a rigorous three-to-four month fermentation process). The reason for the benefit for lactic acid fermentation in skin care may simply be the production of lactic acid, an alpha-hydroxy acid, although this has not been demonstrated as of yet in research.
The sodium RNA contained in the new Advanced Night Repair Concentrate has no known anti-aging benefits. Within most of your body cells, including that of the skin, during transcription, an enzyme called RNA transcriptase recognizes and reads DNA, copying it to form a product called messenger RNA (mRNA). During translation, mRNA is translated by the ribosomes, which in turn produce proteins from the messages encoded in mRNA. However, topically applying the sodium RNA found in Esteé Lauder Advanced Night Repair Concentrate to your skin does not that the sodium RNA diffuses into your cells, that your ribosomes can even recognize the RNA, or, if both of these events did somehow occur, that your skin cells even benefit from the proteins encoded by sodium RNA. A general side note: Although the Human Genome Project made science more exciting, it did nothing as of yet for the world of beauty products, so please do not be duped by any fancy terminology of genetics when buying your skin care.
Is either product really worth the money?
The company does not lie when it claims that the product “soothes daily irritation and builds a rich reserve of anti-oxidants and lipids to help replenish skin’s natural protectants.” For soothing and hydration alone, there are not many products better than the original Esteé Lauder Advanced Night Repair. The product contains very high concentrations of soothing and hydrating ingredients, and the formulation provides a texture many women find appealing. For the $46.50 price for 1 oz., if irritation and dry skin are primary main concerns, then this is an excellent product for you. However, for the reasons addressed above, the new ingredients in Esteé Lauder Advanced Night Repair Concentrate do not seem effective enough to make it worth nearly twice the price of the original, with an MSRP of $85.00 for 1 oz.
For both products, the term “advanced” is rather misleading. Unlike the anti-aging potential of sirtuins available in Avon Anew Ultimate Age Repair Elixir Serum and Night Cream or the potential long-term glycoaminoglycan production that may be stimulated by L’Oréal Skin Genesis and Lancôme Absolue Premium Bx, Esteé Lauder Advanced Night Repair contains nothing that is particularly technologically advanced in skincare. And with the exception of linoleic acid, Esteé Lauder Advanced Night Repair Concentrate is no more revolutionary than the original. Although both products contain a fair amount of network antioxidants, more potent antioxidants are available, and certainly higher concentrations of retinyl palmitate.
So, overall, to buy or not to buy?
If dryness and irritation are primary concerns, then Esteé Lauder Advanced Night Repair is a wonderful product. And if you are severely dry or prone to irritation, Esteé Lauder Advanced Night Repair Concentrate may be somewhat more hydrating and soothing, although no data have been produced to verify this. and the concentrate does cost nearly twice as much as the original.
If anti-aging is the primary concern, then better results would most likely be produced from a nightly retinoid (such as Retin-A), a daily combination of network antioxidants (such as that found in Skinceuticals CE Ferulic), or a more potent antioxidant (such as the coffee berry found in Revalé Skin). Overall, a good hydrating/soothing product, but not an advanced anti-aging product. 7.5/10.
Ingredients of Esteé Lauder Advanced Night Repair
water (aqua purificata) purified, polysaccharides/glycoprotein, methyl gluceth-20, peg-75, butylene glycol, dimethicone copolyol, octyl methoxycinnamate, pantethine, sodium hyaluronate, kola (cola acuminata) extract, hydrogenated lecithin, glycereth-26, matricaria (anthemis nobilis), retinyl palmitate, tocopheryl acetate, bisabolol, oleth-3, oleth-5, squalane, oleth-3 phosphate, choleth-24, cetheth-25, xanthan gum, allatoin, tea-carbomer, trisodium edta, bht, benzyl alcohol, phenoxyethanol, methylparaben, butylparaben, yellow no. 5 (CI 19140), red no. 4 (CI 14700), green no. 5 (CI 61570))
[...] Find the link to this great post here [...]
Pingback by Skin Care » Blog Archive » Product Review: Esteé Lauder Advanced Night Repair versus Advanced ... | October 13, 2007 |
[...] futurederm wrote a fantastic post today on “Product Review: Esteé Lauder Advanced Night Repair versus Advanced …”Here’s ONLY a quick extractAccording to Sone Toshiro, lactic acid fermentation of raw plant materials may have some beneficial skin care benefits (for instance, another Esteé Lauder-owned product, Creme de la Mer, undergoes a rigorous three-to-four month … [...]
Pingback by www.cellulitediary.info » Product Review: Esteé Lauder Advanced Night Repair versus Advanced … | October 14, 2007 |
My daughter (aged
applied a very small amount of this product to her face, which I wiped off when I caught her, thinking she was doing a positive thing – (I should have washed it off immediately) she had a severe reaction to it – redness, stinging and small bumps, after 3 days it has still not subsided – makes one wonder about the ingredients!
I want to know whether lechitin you are using in your product(lipstick) is from animal source or plant? I would appreciate the reply from you. Thank you
I find this product review very helpfull. But I have to admit estee lauder advanced night repair concentrate does far more then the original night repair. I have used this product for three months consecutively and started noticing the first major difference on my skin in two weeks. After a month my face was moren even toned and looked more rested. After three months small lines around my eyes and mouth were started to fade away. Without exaggerating, I feel and look like a new person. This is by far the most expensive product Ive used, but worth every penny!
As a woman in my early 20’s I swear by this product and have had many friends begin using it. I have started my friends on this product and after 4 weeks even their boyfriends and husbands have commented on how good their skin is looking.
I cannot understand why advanced products like Esstee Lauder use lavender in their product,it is not only a skin irritant but also has been found to cause cell death according to Paulas Choice a cosmatic cop.
Ich kann nicht glauben, dass ein Produkt, dass man sich ins Gesicht streicht, eine Wirkung auf die RNA hat.
I am 22 years old and I’ve always had problems with acne.I’ve tried everything ,even proactive and nothing worked,it was just making my skin look worse.Anyway one day I was walking by the Estele Lauder products,the lady working there told me to try this product,and she gave me a few samples.I could see the result right the way.Of course next week I went right back and bought the whole package.My skin looks better than never.No more bumps or redness,now is incredibly smooth and it was totally worth the money.Thanks Sally from Great northern Mall.
I am 36 years old. I started using this product in my 20’s and stopped for a while and then started again about 7 months ago. I am very happy with this product. I use the idealist in the mornings and the night repair before bed. I tell all my friends about it and they are using it as well and happy about the results. I have seen a big difference in the texture of my face when I use these products. I still look like i’m in my 20’s. Thank you so much for coming out with this product!
Awful! I’ve got severe reaction with rash and bumps and can’t rid of it for a month!
I’ve never had any allergies in my life, and have to go to a dermatologist now!
whomever wrote this is a genius!!! very true and this product is great…but since ive bleached my skin, it hurts to use it now because it stings…beware dont use obagi clear bleaching cream…it leaves u whiter than white if Ur already pale like me and…u will look like a jackson…latoya to be specific…
i wonder if la mer the concentrate is comparable to the advanced night repair serum…i dont know weather la mer is worth 230 dls and la mer concentrate is worth 350 dls.? anyone can tell me if they have used la mer concentrate and if it is worth spending that money?
Love this product and have used off and on for over 25 years; have found ANR very helpful to alternate with RetinA to avoid the excessive irritation the prescription stuff does to my skin. Best testimonial is that 24-year old law student daughter wanted some because she admires how young my skin still is at 56!